Looking beyond the label “reactive”
About this research
This page summarises findings from my PhD research investigating dog–dog reactivity. The study explored whether dogs described as “reactive” represent a single behavioural group or whether distinct behavioural patterns exist.
Dog–dog reactivity is one of the most common reasons dogs are referred for behavioural medicine. Owners often describe dogs as “reactive” because they bark, lunge, growl or snap when they encounter another dog.
Why this research was needed
The term reactive is widely used by owners, trainers and behaviour professionals, yet to date there has been no universally accepted definition of what a “dog reactive dog” actually is.
Before investigating behavioural patterns, the first step was therefore to establish a working definition based on the experiences of people who live and work with these dogs.
Owners and professionals were asked how they recognised a reactive dog. Their responses consistently described behaviours such as barking, growling, snarling, lunging, snapping, nipping, biting, whining, and a stiff posture with raised hackles and intense staring. These behaviours therefore formed the working definition used throughout the study.
Are all dog reactive dogs the same?
If two dogs both bark and lunge towards another dog, should they receive the same behavioural advice?
Or could those outward behaviours reflect different emotional states, motivations and levels of risk?
Understanding these differences has important implications for behavioural assessment, treatment planning and welfare.
How the Research Was Conducted
The study collected information from almost 2,000 owners of dogs displaying reactive behaviour towards other dogs. More than 1,300 complete behavioural profiles were included in the final analysis.
We explored whether certain behaviours tended to occur together and whether distinct patterns existed within the wider population of dog reactive dogs. This approach allowed the analysis to move beyond simple labels such as “barks” or “lunges” and instead investigate the overall structure of reactive behaviour.
The analysis showed that reactive behaviours occurred in consistent patterns rather than at random.
What Did the Research Find?
Posturing
This included growling, snarling and a stiff posture with intense staring. These behaviours appear to function primarily as threat displays and communication signals.
Frustration
This pattern was characterised by barking, lunging and whining. These behaviours may reflect situations where a dog’s movement or behaviour is restricted, such as when held on a lead, resulting in heightened frustration and arousal.
Oral Attack
This included snapping, nipping and biting. These behaviours involve physical contact or attempted contact and represent a different aspect of behavioural escalation.
Together, these three behavioural patterns explained much of the variation seen across the population of reactive dogs.
Four Behavioural Profiles
When these behavioural patterns were examined together, four distinct groups of dog reactive dogs emerged.
Although every dog is an individual, the findings suggest that many reactive dogs can be broadly described as belonging to one of four behavioural profiles.
Low Risk Signallers
Primarily communicative behaviour with little tendency to escalate.
These dogs commonly displayed posturing and frustration-related behaviours but showed very little tendency towards physical contact. These dogs tend to avoid escalation and may prefer avoidance.
Frustrated Escalators
High-arousal behaviour associated with frustration.
These dogs showed particularly high levels of frustration-related behaviour alongside threat displays. Their behaviour suggested a greater risk of escalation under certain circumstances, particularly when unable to move away from a situation.
Impulsive Escalators
Relatively greater tendency towards physical contact.
These dogs showed relatively higher levels of physical contact behaviours despite only moderate frustration. This pattern suggests that factors such as impulsivity, rapid escalation or previous learning may play an important role.
Risky Rapid Escalators
High levels across all behavioural patterns.
These dogs were characterised by very high levels across all three behavioural patterns and represented the group with the greatest tendency to escalate rapidly during interactions with other dogs.
The Most Important Finding
Key finding
Dogs described as “reactive” are not all the same.
Dogs displaying similar outward behaviours may differ substantially in how they communicate, how readily they escalate and the emotional processes underlying their behaviour. This suggests that behavioural assessment should move beyond simply identifying whether a dog is “reactive” and instead consider how that reactivity is expressed.
Why Does This Matter?
Behavioural medicine aims to understand why behaviour occurs rather than simply suppressing it.
If different patterns of reactive behaviour reflect different underlying emotional or behavioural processes, then assessment and treatment should also be individualised.
The findings from this research support a more tailored approach to behavioural medicine, recognising that two dogs displaying similar outward behaviours may benefit from different management and treatment strategies.
How This Influences My Clinical Work
My clinical approach is informed by both the wider behavioural medicine evidence and my own research into dog–dog reactivity.
Rather than focusing solely on the behaviours owners can see, I aim to understand the underlying emotional, medical and environmental factors that contribute to each individual dog’s behaviour. This allows treatment plans to be tailored to the individual animal, recognising that no two dogs even those with similar behavioural presentations are exactly alike.
Dog Reactivity Screening Tool
As part of the research, we developed a free screening tool that estimates which behavioural profile a dog most closely resembles. It is intended for educational purposes and may help owners better understand how reactive behaviour can vary between individuals.
Take the Dog Reactivity Screening ToolThe screening tool is not intended to diagnose behaviour problems or replace a behavioural medicine consultation.
Continuing the Research
This study represents one step towards improving our understanding of dog–dog reactivity.
Future research will continue to explore how these behavioural patterns develop, how they relate to learning, impulsivity and emotional state, and whether different treatment approaches are more effective for different behavioural profiles.
Read the Original Research
This page summarises the findings in owner-friendly language. If you would like to explore the full methodology, statistical analysis and complete results, you can access the publication below.
Reactive and Risky: The behavioural structuring of dog reactive dogs
Van Haevermaet H, Soulsbury CD, Mills DS.
Applied Animal Behaviour Science (2026)